Yogācāraयोगाचार

Pariniṣpanna: the consummate nature

pariniṣpanna-svabhāva · 圓成實性 yuánchéng shí xìng / enjōjitsu shō, "real, perfect and consummate nature"

Pariniṣpanna is the consummate nature: the permanent absence of the subject-object projection in the dependent. It is neither a beyond nor a content, but the same experience without the projection.

Pariniṣpanna-svabhāva, the consummate nature (圓成實性 yuánchéng shí xìng, Jap. enjōjitsu shō, "real, perfect and consummate nature"), is the third of the three natures. It is the permanent absence of the dualistic projection in the dependent. It is not an additional thing: it is a subtraction.

The definition

Triṃśikā 21 (see Triṃśikā) describes it as tasya pūrveṇa sadā rahitatā, "the constant absence in it of the former." Trisvabhāva-nirdeśa 3 (see Trisvabhāvanirdeśa) says the same in other terms: the perpetual absence, in what appears, of the imagined way of appearing. In two treatises, and in almost the same words, what defines the third nature is an absence, never a content. Paramārtha (see Paramārtha) translates it as 真實性 zhēnshí xìng, "true nature."

Trisvabhāva-nirdeśa 4 formulates the question and the answer: what appears is the imagination of the unreal (see Abhūtaparikalpa: The Imagination of the Unreal); it appears in the form of duality; and its non-existence consists in that by which there is there the nature of non-duality (advaya-dharmatā).

Not another place

The most surprising consequence is that the pariniṣpanna is not a state one reaches by going somewhere else. It is this very experience, minus the projection. The image of the space of a room helps: one does not manufacture the space by removing the furniture, and it was not hidden behind the furniture either. Space is no thing at all; removing the furniture neither produces nor reveals an object, it merely ceases to obstruct.

Verse 22 of the Triṃśikā adds that the consummate is neither other than nor not other than the dependent, as impermanence is in relation to impermanent things. The revolution of the basis is the turning of the dependent itself, not the passage to a separate domain.

Several names for one thing

The texts name the consummate nature in different ways, and each name looks from a different angle:

  • tathatā, 真如 zhēnrú (Jap. shinnyo), "suchness": things are thus and not otherwise (see Tathatā: suchness).
  • dharmatā: the proper mode of phenomena, not a property added to them.
  • advaya, "non-duality": says which structure has ceased to operate.
  • śūnyatā, "emptiness": says what is lacking, here the grāhya-grāhaka duality (see Emptiness without Nihilism).

Verse 25 of the Triṃśikā calls it the ultimate meaning of the dharmas and identifies it with suchness and with representation-only itself. Xuánzàng (see Xuánzàng) reads suchness as the "real nature" (實性 shíxìng) of consciousness-only, a subtle difference that carries weight in interpretation.

How one arrives

According to the Trisvabhāva-nirdeśa, access is a movement in three linked moments. First one understands that everything that appears is representation (vijñapti-mātra). With this, one no longer finds an object to be grasped (grāhya). Without an object, the grasping subject (grāhaka) also dissolves, since each exists in function of the other. The mind then rests in non-duality. This rest is not a blank or a torpor, but a lucid cognition, which sees without splitting. For the path that prepares this, see The Five Stages of the Path and The ten bodhisattva grounds, and for its fruit, The Four Wisdoms.

Neither fullness nor annihilation

The constant temptation is to make the third nature a fullness waiting to be found. It is not emptiness in the sense of annihilation, nor a full content. The difference is the one between a room without furniture and a room full of light. And it is accessible to knowledge, even if words do not reach it.

It should not be confused with the idealism of an Absolute: negating the subject-object division is not equivalent to affirming a single mind (see Idealism or phenomenology?).

The corresponding absence

It corresponds to the absence of nature in the ultimate sense (paramārtha-niḥsvabhāvatā). Note: it is not said that the pariniṣpanna is empty like the other two, but that it is that emptiness. See The Three Absences of Nature.

In summary

  • The pariniṣpanna is the dependent defined by the lack of the imagined projection.
  • It is a subtraction, neither a beyond nor a content.
  • It receives the names of suchness, dharmatā, non-duality and emptiness.
  • It is accessed through the revolution of the basis, which transforms the flow and does not destroy it.