This section gathers texts of longer argumentation than the entries. While the pages of Doctrine, Texts and Masters describe the material, the articles take a position on a problem that runs through several entries, and justify it with the sources. Each can be read alone, but all return to the reading the site adopts: Yogācāra as an analysis of experience, and not as idealist metaphysics (see What Is Yogācāra and Idealism or phenomenology?).
The articles
- Why Yogācāra Is Not Idealism: what the thesis of representation-only (Vijñaptimātra: representation-only) affirms and what it does not; the idealist, phenomenological and pluralist readings; the role of representation-only itself as a step to be overcome.
- The Ālaya and the Unconscious: Similarities and Differences: the Ālaya-vijñāna: The Storehouse Consciousness compared with Western notions of the unconscious, with attention to what is shared, what differs and the risks of reading the ālaya as a hidden or collective self.
- Manas: The Fabrication of the Self: the fabrication of the self by the seventh consciousness (Kliṣṭa-manas: the Seventh Consciousness), its four afflictions, its uninterrupted activity and its relation to the thinking of the sixth.
- Seeds and Habits: Karma as Learning: karma as a process of learning, read through Bīja: the seeds and Vāsanā: the impregnations, with the limits of that analogy.
How to use this section
The articles presuppose familiarity with the basic vocabulary. Those who arrive for the first time can begin with Introduction and with the section The Mind: The Eight Consciousnesses, where the eight consciousnesses are presented. Quotations from classical texts come from the translations of the Compendium of Yogācāra Studies, made from the Sanskrit and the Chinese versions; references to modern scholars are attributed and verified against the studies consulted (Bibliography of studies).
Criteria
The articles follow the site's general rule: no author, classical or modern, is credited with what he did not write; the idealist reading is presented fairly before being criticized; and the terminology is that of the project glossary (for example, vijñaptimātra is "representation-only" and cittamātra, "mind-only", as in Cittamātra).
Subtopics
Why Yogācāra Is Not Idealism
Why the thesis of representation-only does not amount to saying that the world is mere idea: what Vasubandhu denies, what he does not deny, and how the phenomenological reading answers the idealist reading.
2The Ālaya and the Unconscious: Similarities and Differences
A careful comparison between the storehouse consciousness and Western notions of the unconscious: what they have in common (subliminal level, memory, habit) and what sets them apart (body, karmic maturation, absence of agency, transformability).
3Manas: The Fabrication of the Self
How the seventh consciousness takes the stream of the ālaya for a self: object, four afflictions, uninterrupted activity, circuit with the other consciousnesses and the difference from the thinking of the sixth.
4Seeds and Habits: Karma as Learning
Karma read through the key of seeds and impregnations: each experience leaves a tendency that conditions the next, which makes karma a process of learning and not a destiny.